Trail Gear Advisor

How to Choose Golf Balls: Used vs. New, Soft Feel or Urethane Control?

Compare four golf balls by listed price, used versus new condition, package size, color, and performance emphasis to choose between distance, Soft Feel, or urethane control.

Last updated Aug 26, 2026

Quick take

Choosing golf balls means balancing how a ball is described for play against price, package size, and whether used condition works for you. These four choices range across recycled used balls, new balls, white, color-mix, and yellow designs. The quickest route is to decide condition first, then compare package format and the performance emphasis that best matches your round.

The practical split is simple: the TaylorMade TP5 X and Callaway Supersoft Matte Mix are used recycled choices, while TaylorMade Tour Response and the Yellow Soft Feel PWRCORE ball are new. Listed prices, package sizes, and color make the final choice more specific.

Listed-price comparison

Golf ballListed pricePrice bar
TaylorMade TP5 X Used Golf Balls$13.59
Callaway Supersoft Matte Mix Used Golf Balls$58.65
TaylorMade Tour Response Golf Balls$65.99
Yellow Soft Feel PWRCORE Golf Balls$22.95

Decision matrix

  • Condition: TaylorMade TP5 X and Callaway Supersoft Matte Mix are used recycled balls. TaylorMade Tour Response and Yellow Soft Feel PWRCORE are new.
  • Package size: TaylorMade TP5 X is identified as 12 balls, Callaway as 72 Count, and Yellow Soft Feel PWRCORE as 1 dozen. Tour Response is compared here by its ball construction, material, and control emphasis instead of package size.
  • Listed emphasis: Distance is identified for TaylorMade TP5 X and Callaway Supersoft Matte Mix. Control is identified for Tour Response, while the Yellow Soft Feel title emphasizes Soft Feel and high visibility.
  • Color: TaylorMade TP5 X and Tour Response are white, Callaway uses a color mix, and Yellow Soft Feel PWRCORE is yellow.

Product notes

TaylorMade TP5 X Used Golf Balls, Near Mint Condition, AAAA Quality

TaylorMade TP5 X Used Golf Balls, Near Mint Condition, AAAA Quality

At $13.59, this is the lowest listed price in the group and a straightforward pick for a golfer who wants a 12-ball pack with Distance among its listed features. The title calls out near mint condition and AAAA quality. The balls are white, recycled, and used, giving the choice a clear identity for shoppers comfortable with used balls. The limitation is condition: it is not a new pack. Choose it when the near-mint wording, white color, and distance emphasis fit the plan; choose TaylorMade Tour Response when new condition is non-negotiable.

Callaway Supersoft Matte Mix Used Golf Balls, Good Quality, 72 Count

Callaway Supersoft Matte Mix Used Golf Balls, Good Quality, 72 Count

At $58.65, the Callaway Supersoft Matte Mix is the package-size choice: the title specifies 72 Count, and Distance appears among its listed features. Its color mix suits a golfer who wants variety rather than one displayed color. The title describes the balls as used and good quality, while the ball type is recycled. The limitation is that the pack is used and color-mixed, so it is not the fit for someone seeking new condition or a single white or yellow look. Pick Callaway when quantity and mixed color lead the decision; choose a new or single-color design when those priorities change.

TaylorMade Tour Response Golf Balls

New TaylorMade Tour Response Golf Balls 2 Dozen Urethane Golf Balls

TaylorMade Tour Response Golf Balls is a direct match for a shopper who specifically wants a new golf ball with urethane material and a Control feature. The ball type is Tour Preferred and construction is 3-piece. Its description adds soft feel, fast ball speed, consistent flight, and greenside control for a tour-inspired playing profile. At $65.99, it has the highest listed price here, which is the main practical limitation. It is also white, so a golfer choosing primarily for yellow visibility or a color mix has more direct matches elsewhere. Choose Tour Response when new condition, urethane, and control matter more than the lowest entry price.

Yellow Soft Feel PWRCORE Golf Balls

1 Dozen Yellow Low Compression Golf Balls Soft Feel High Visibility PWRCORE

Yellow Soft Feel PWRCORE is a new, yellow choice for golfers who put color and the title's Soft Feel wording near the top of the list. The same title calls out high visibility, and the package is identified as one dozen. At $22.95, it offers a direct route to the listed color-and-feel profile without moving to the new urethane Tour Response. The limitation is package size: one dozen is smaller than the 72-count Callaway pack. Choose it for the yellow, high-visibility presentation; choose another design when used condition or a larger package is the deciding factor.

Final recommendation by use case

  • For the lowest listed-price route: TaylorMade TP5 X.
  • For a larger-package decision: Callaway Supersoft Matte Mix.
  • For new-ball shoppers focused on the control wording: TaylorMade Tour Response.
  • For a yellow, Soft Feel choice: Yellow Soft Feel PWRCORE.

For a beginner or a golfer replacing balls for everyday rounds, start with the used-versus-new decision rather than trying to optimize every specification at once. The used choices emphasize distance, Tour Response centers on urethane and control, and Yellow Soft Feel PWRCORE keeps the decision focused on color and feel.

Products in this article
TaylorMade TP5 X Used Golf BallsUSD 13.59View on eBayCallaway Supersoft Matte Mix Used Golf BallsUSD 58.65View on eBayNew TaylorMade Tour Response Golf Balls 2 Dozen Urethane Golf BallsUSD 65.99View on eBay1 Dozen Yellow Low Compression Golf Balls Soft Feel High Visibility PWRCOREUSD 22.95View on eBay
TaylorMade TP5 X Used Golf BallsUSD 13.59View on eBayCallaway Supersoft Matte Mix Used Golf BallsUSD 58.65View on eBayNew TaylorMade Tour Response Golf Balls 2 Dozen Urethane Golf BallsUSD 65.99View on eBay1 Dozen Yellow Low Compression Golf Balls Soft Feel High Visibility PWRCOREUSD 22.95View on eBay

You may also like

Finding more guides for you…